Critical Essay


Roberto Roberti and the Contemporary Significance of Historical Photographic Processes by Grzegorz Gorczynski

The stone face from the Bayon Temple in Cambodia bears the marks of centuries of time. In Roberto Roberti’s photograph, cracks, joints in the stone blocks, and surface irregularities are clearly visible. The calm expression remains almost unchanged despite the sculpture’s material degradation. The photographer presents it in cyanotype, which imbues the stone with an intense blue and removes the natural coloring of the surrounding vegetation. The image’s boundaries are marked by irregular traces of the photosensitive layer. The stone sculpture, whose creator remained outside contemporary experience, meets here the visible gesture of the photographer’s hand. This meeting of two temporally distant artistic activities allows us to perceive a problem that transcends the aesthetics of cyanotype. Roberto Roberti does not alter the appearance of the sculpture itself by intervening in its physical structure. However, he transforms the way it is presented and experienced. The historical photographic process contributes to creating a distance between the actual site and its image, while the irregular border of the print reminds us that we are viewing the result of a contemporary creative activity. Photography is not a transparent window into the past. It is an object made here and now, with a specific intention and using consciously selected materials.

This relationship between the image and its material realization constitutes one of the most important challenges in the contemporary use of alternative techniques. In the age of digital photography, an image can exist, be distributed, and perceived without the need for a permanent material form. A print has become a choice, and this choice can have significance that transcends the need to present a photograph on paper. What is particularly interesting about Roberto Roberti’s practice is that he assigns different roles to different processes. Palladiotype allows him primarily to realize a previously formed image, while gum bichromate opens up the possibility of further transformations. This difference raises the question of the limits of authorship: at what point is a photograph considered complete, and who decides the extent of its further changes?

This issue has a long history. Photographers associated with pictorialism at the turn of the 20th century sought ways to express individual artistic vision in a medium whose mechanical nature often became an argument against its recognition as art. For some, the negative was merely a starting point. The choice of process, paper, pigments, and the extent of manual intervention enabled the creation of prints differing both in visual properties and the degree of the artist’s transformation of the representation. In his article ” On the Straight Print ,” published in 1907 in “Camera Work,” Robert Demachy participated in a debate concerning the artistic significance of a print made without subsequent modifications and one subjected to conscious intervention.[1] At stake in this debate was not so much the superiority of one technique over the other, but the possibility of defining photography as a creative activity.

A particularly telling example remains Edward Steichen’s The Flatiron . The artist made a negative of a New York skyscraper in 1904 and then produced color-distinct prints, combining platinum type with gum bichromate. Extant examples demonstrate how variations in pigment and process properties can imbue the same motif with distinct characters. The Metropolitan Museum of Art holds, among others, versions made in 1905 and 1909.[2] Each remains linked to the same photographic representation, but the method of materialization contributes to shaping its individual form. A print can thus be a realization of an earlier image, and simultaneously a space for subsequent artistic decisions.

Roberto Roberti tackles a similar problem in fundamentally different conditions from those in which historical pictorialists worked. He uses digital cameras, graphics software, and negatives printed on transparent materials, then makes contact prints using processes dating back to the 19th century. He doesn’t attempt to recreate the entire historical photographer’s technique. He selects elements that correspond to his concept of the image, while retaining the freedom offered by modern technology. This is a conscious hybrid practice, in which old and new methods don’t compete with each other but rather participate in the successive stages of photographic creation.

Roberto Roberti’s path to such choices, however, began far removed from contemporary discussions of post-photography. In 2009, he photographed abandoned industrial complexes, treating their documentation as a form of observing social change. Over time, his interest in neglected plants gave way to a fascination with the industrial architecture of Lombardy and Piedmont, particularly structures from the first half of the 20th century. He cites Pier Luigi Nervi among his most important artists, whose work allowed him to discern formal values ​​in industrial buildings independent of their utilitarian function. At the same time, he developed landscape photography. During his mountain hikes, he was fascinated by the variability of light, the structure of space, and the possibility of achieving images that departed from direct visual experience. Initially, he used black-and-white films, including Fujifilm Neopan, and infrared materials. Long exposures and a conscious restraint on the natural properties of representation were intended to create an atmosphere that he did not associate with documentary literalness. A common thread can be discerned between these seemingly disparate interests. The abandoned factory and the mountain landscape reveal different modes of time’s presence. The former bears traces of human activity, whose original function has been interrupted. The latter can appear unchanging, yet is subject to constant transformation. In both cases, the photographer seeks an image that allows him to go beyond the immediate information about the appearance of the place. It should not be assumed, however, that he consciously developed a single, coherent concept of transience from the outset. Rather, it is a recognizable connection between the successive stages of his work, one that gains significance in light of his later statements.

Painting also played an important role. Roberto Roberti recalls that, thanks to his father, a collector of works of art and antiques, he grew up surrounded by paintings. He attaches particular importance to the chiaroscuro of Caravaggio and Rembrandt, the atmosphere of Impressionism, and the formal synthesis of abstract art. In pictorialism, he recognized an aesthetic approach that corresponded to his own way of seeing. He is not interested in mechanically imitating old photographs, but in the possibility of creating representations in which composition, light, and tone lead to an experience that goes beyond the recognition of the photographed subject. In the responses provided for this research project, the artist emphasizes that photography should stimulate the viewer’s imagination.[3] He invokes an analogy to bonsai, whose limited form can suggest a vast landscape, and the Japanese concept of yūgen , associated with mystery and understatement. He also draws on a Romantic understanding of the sublime. These are elements of his own aesthetic language, not evidence of adherence to a specific philosophical school. However, they allow us to understand why he attaches so much importance to the selection of motifs and the ability to extract meaning from a limited fragment of reality.

A honeymoon trip to Cambodia marked the beginning of an extensive project photographing sacred architecture. In the following years, Roberto Roberti visited temples and historic buildings in various parts of the world. It was this desire to give material form to photographs of ancient sanctuaries that led him to alternative techniques. In a 2018 article in Platinum Palladium for Digital Photographers , he explained that he was interested in the print as an object whose properties could not be reduced to the image viewed on a screen.[4] Therefore, this was not a simple return to old methods for sentimental reasons. The historical process was intended to achieve a specific character of representation.

One work that helps better understand this decision is a palladiotype depicting a fragment of a temple in Cambodia, described in the artist’s portfolio as a photograph of the architecture of Angkor Wat. Ornamentation, stone columns, and dark architectural openings create an image with distinctly differentiated tonal qualities. Light highlights the details of the carved surfaces, while deep shadows maintain a sense of spatial inaccessibility within the interior. The composition leads the eye from the richly detailed details toward the darker sections of the structure. Its fundamental significance stems from the relationship between the visible richness of the material and the areas that remain beyond full recognition. In such a photograph, the palladiotype seems to respond to Roberto Roberti’s declared need to preserve subtle tonal differences. The artist does not seek to completely dissolve the architectural structure in a painterly atmosphere. The stone reliefs remain legible, and the character of the print enhances their presentation. The material does not replace the photographed object, but rather enables the realization of an image whose basic composition has been previously determined. This is an important example of a technique subordinated to artistic intent, rather than a demonstration of one’s own capabilities.

A palladium print depicting a person on a small boat on Lake Tonlé Sap in Cambodia has a different character. The narrow boat, the surrounding water, and dense vegetation create a horizontally extended composition. The figure is positioned near the center of the frame, yet the surrounding space retains its own visual intensity. The light sections of the water and vegetation contrast with the darker silhouette of the man and boat. The image combines an element of observation of everyday life with a formally structured presentation. This photograph is particularly important because it demonstrates that Roberto Roberti’s interest in historical processes is not limited to depicting historic architecture. Palladiotype also serves to materialize scenes of contemporary life. We do not receive a timeless image in the literal sense, but a photograph of a specific situation in which the choice of process changes the perception of the relationship between people and their surrounding environment. It also serves as a counterexample to the too-easy identification of his work with the aesthetics of ruins and sacred buildings. Both prints also reveal the irregular boundaries of the hand-applied photosensitive layer. This is a significant detail that complicates the simple distinction between palladiotype as a process faithful to the image and gum bichromate as a space for manual intervention. The palladium print also retains the trace of the hand’s action. The difference, then, lies not in the presence or absence of a manual gesture, but in the extent to which Roberto Roberti allows this gesture to influence the underlying structure of the representation.

The artist himself clearly distinguishes between these two situations. He explains that once a RAW file is developed, the composition and tone of the image are fundamentally determined. Making a palladium print aims to preserve this structure, imparting properties related to tonal range and the paper’s surface. He views gum bichromate differently. Subsequent layers of pigment, color selection, exposure, and development methods allow for further transformations of the photograph. In this case, the process becomes, for him, a truly painterly creative activity.

A good example is a gum bichromate print depicting a section of the Mehrangarh Fort in Rajasthan. At the center of the image is a richly decorated architectural element, whose composition is built by successive arches and rhythmically placed ornaments. Their geometric regularity is contrasted with the print’s irregular edge, where extensive brushwork is clearly visible. The brownish-red coloring distances the representation from the natural appearance of the stone while simultaneously lending it a visual uniformity. What’s interesting about this work is the way two distinct formal orders meet. The architecture is organized according to rigorous principles of symmetry and decoration. The print’s edge, on the other hand, is the result of a more liberal application of the photosensitive layer. The first order belongs to the photographed object, the second to the contemporary process of image making. The gum bichromate does not eliminate the photographic clarity of the architecture, but clearly highlights the presence of a distinct material layer. It is impossible to determine all the changes that occurred during subsequent exposures and development based on a reproduction. We also cannot assess the actual texture of the pigment without viewing the original. However, it can be argued that the way the print’s surface is treated is a visible element of its composition. The hand-crafted border is not entirely decorative. It introduces a tension between the regularity of the depicted architecture and the variability of its materialization process.

A similar relationship can be observed in a gum bichromate painting depicting a fountain in Catania. Its central element is a male figure depicted against a backdrop of urban architecture. The presence of water, stone, and architectural elements creates an image of an urban space in which the historic sculptural form remains part of the contemporary environment. The print is maintained in a restrained tone, and the irregular border of the image once again highlights the handmade method of its execution. This work demonstrates that Roberto Roberti’s interest in the materiality of historical motifs does not necessarily lead to images completely detached from everyday life. The fountain exists simultaneously as an artistic object and a functional element of the urban space. Photographing it in gum bichromate highlights the sculpture’s qualities without removing its architectural context. In this case, the process serves not only to create an atmosphere of antiquity; it also allows for the photograph to approximate a graphic interpretation of the representation.

Comparing these works with palladiotypes allows for a better understanding of the most important distinction present in Roberto Roberti’s practice. The choice of technique does not, in itself, determine the character of the work. The artist decides what role the process will play in the existing image. They may strive to preserve the subtle tonal gradations and pre-existing structure of the photograph, or allow for its further transformation through pigment and multi-layered paper processing. Both approaches require conscious decisions, although the extent of intervention differs.

This leads to a more important recognition than a simple contrast between photography and painting. In palladiotype, Roberto Roberti consciously limits the scope of changes that should occur after the negative is processed. In gum bichromate, he expands this possibility. His authorship is thus revealed both in the intervention and in the decision to refrain from it. In the former, responsibility for the image consists in protecting the previously achieved composition; in the latter, it encompasses consent to further shaping the representation. Authorship understood in this way need not be identified with the number of manual steps or the degree of technological complexity of the process. Its foundation is the ability to recognize what a specific photograph requires. In some situations, further intervention can enrich the representation, in others it could compromise its intended character. The boundary between these possibilities is not inherent in the technology itself. It is drawn by the artist. This recognition should not be considered a universal definition of palladiotype and gum bichromate. Other artists may use the two processes quite differently. Palladiotype also allows for numerous decisions regarding the image, and gum bichromate can be used with the intention of reproducing the negative as faithfully as possible. In the case of Roberto Roberti, however, the above division stems from his own statements and is partially confirmed by the visible properties of his works. It is therefore a characteristic of an individual practice, not a general classification of alternative techniques.

It’s also worth noting that conscious image control doesn’t guarantee complete predictability of the result. Roberto Roberti prepares digital negatives, whose characteristics must be appropriately adapted to the process and exposure device. In a 2018 article, he described months of experiments calibrating negatives for palladium prints.[4] In gum bichromate, however, variations in pigment, humidity, and the development process require making successive decisions during the process. Technical precision doesn’t completely eliminate uncertainty, but it does define a space within which the artist can control it or creatively utilize it.

What’s also particularly interesting is that the development of this individual practice didn’t occur in isolation. Roberto Roberti cites Giorgio Bordin and Roberto Lagresta as the individuals from whom he acquired his knowledge of historical photographic processes. Together with Misha Cattabiani, he worked on the preparation of digital negatives and the UV exposure device, and he also benefited from the help of Andrea Dall’Olio in perfecting gum bichromate. These accounts demonstrate that even where the final print is made independently, its creation depends on knowledge developed and passed on by others. This is significant for understanding authorship. Individual artistic decisions don’t arise in a technological vacuum. They are made possible by a specific set of materials, skills, and experiences. Roberto Roberti remains the author of his photographs and prints, but his practice is simultaneously part of a contemporary environment that maintains the continuity of historical processes. This connection doesn’t diminish the individuality of the work. Instead, it allows us to discern the social conditions that allow individual creativity to flourish.

The significance of the material form of photography becomes even clearer when we consider Roberto Roberti’s understanding of the function of prints. The artist repeatedly emphasizes that photography should physically exist, be viewed, and occupy a place in the human environment. He is not satisfied with images available solely on a screen. He links the creation of prints to the need for direct contact with the work, its surface, and its actual scale. This perspective can be contrasted with the research of Elizabeth Edwards and Janice Hart, who propose treating photography as an object with its own material and social history. In this approach, a photographic print is not merely a neutral medium of representation. Its properties, manner of storage, presentation, and use all contribute to shaping meaning.[5] This theory does not explain all aspects of Roberto Roberti’s work, but it allows for a better understanding of why the existence of photography as a real object is so important to him.

The photographer criticizes the practice of storing valuable prints exclusively in archival boxes if they are never displayed. He creates works primarily with their presence in the home in mind, both his own and that of those who decide to purchase them. In his view, photography doesn’t fully fulfill its function through its physical existence alone. It also requires a viewer. However, this isn’t an argument against conservation protection. Photographic material requires appropriate storage conditions, and excessive exposure can accelerate its deterioration. Roberto Roberti’s statement reveals a tension between the need to preserve an object and its presence in everyday life. A print stored in an archive preserves the possibility of future viewing, while a photograph permanently displayed remains accessible, but is subject to the effects of light and its surroundings. This tension is particularly interesting in the context of his photographs of historical churches. Roberto Roberti recognizes the paradox inherent in palladiotyping: an image made using relatively durable metal is created on paper, the organic structure of which is itself subject to aging. The photograph thus depicts buildings built with a long-lasting purpose in mind, yet at the same time remains a perishable object. Similarly, a landscape that may appear unchanging is constantly subject to natural processes. Historical technique here is not merely a means of making a contemporary photograph resemble a vintage photograph. It becomes part of a reflection on time. The material from which the image was made has its own history and future, just like the object depicted. However, it is important to distinguish between the artist’s declared durability of the palladiotype and the actual stability of the entire print, which also depends on the paper, storage conditions, and the technological process.

A similar theme can be seen in his Visual Haiku project , though it takes a different form. Instead of monumental architecture, small fragments of landscape appear, often photographed in the forest. Roberto Roberti describes these places as spaces that allow for extended observation and the gradual discovery of composition. Unlike foreign trips, where the photographic plan is subordinated to logistical constraints, the intimate landscape allows for a more relaxed contact with reality. His statements recur with the belief that a small fragment of nature can evoke an experience much broader than the literal recognition of a motif. The point, then, is not the monumentality of the depicted object, but the composition’s ability to spark the imagination. In this understanding, the faces of stone deities, the architecture of ancient temples, and forest micro-landscapes can all participate in a similar quest. Each of these motifs allows for the reduction of visible reality to a selected fragment, to which the photographer imbues a specific emotional intensity. This connection does not necessarily imply complete coherence across all of his projects. Roberto Roberti has tackled various themes, utilized various technologies, and worked in diverse conditions. The value of his practice may lie in his ability to adapt his workflow to specific experiences, rather than consistently subordinating all his photographs to a single formal model. In mountain landscapes, he accepts the variability of weather and time constraints. When photographing sacred architecture, he works according to a pre-prepared plan. In the forest, he can wait and observe. These differences influence the process of image recording before the question of choosing a printing technique arises.

However, there is also a limitation inherent in this aesthetic. Presenting historical sites as mysterious and timeless spaces can lead to the omission of their contemporary social and cultural contexts. In the case of Asian temples, it is particularly important to distinguish between the photographer’s personal experience and the actual meaning of the depicted sites for the people who remain connected to them. Roberto Roberti does not profess to replace history with his own interpretation, but his aesthetic choices consciously shift the focus from documentary information to the atmosphere and symbolic dimension of the image. This limitation does not invalidate the value of such a practice. It merely demonstrates that artistic photography always makes choices, and these choices simultaneously mean extracting certain meanings while leaving others outside the frame. Therefore, the historical process that reinforces the impression of distance from the present should also be analyzed in relation to what it removes from the viewer’s immediate experience.

Roberto Roberti’s stance on color photography deserves similar attention. The artist clearly prefers monochrome, considering it a means to transcend the literalness of representation. Meanwhile, his own gums and cyanotypes demonstrate that color can serve an interpretive function. The brownish-red tones of the photographs of the Mehrangarh Fort and the intense blue of the Bayon stone face do not reproduce the natural color of the photographed objects. Instead, they structure their perception. In the photographer’s practice, the distinction between descriptive color and color that consciously shapes the meaning of a representation seems more important than the mere division between color and black-and-white. This distinction may be one of the most interesting aspects of his work, as it reveals the connection between his declared monochromatic aesthetic and the actual use of pigment. Roberto Roberti does not need to alter his own preferences for this relationship to become a subject of reflection. It is enough to note that in his prints, color is not completely rejected, but appears where it can become a tool for transforming the image.

The contemporary significance of this practice is also revealed in the artist’s relationship with digital technology and artificial intelligence. Roberto Roberti makes no secret of his critical stance towards the culture of images subordinated to the rapid circulation of the internet. He is concerned about the homogenization of photography, the popularity of ready-made visual effects, and the increasing difficulty in distinguishing documentary images from digitally generated ones. He sees in historical processes the possibility of preserving a special relationship between the author, the material, and the viewer. However, a physical print cannot automatically be considered proof of the authenticity of a representation. An image generated by AI can also be transferred to a digital negative and produced in gum bichromate or palladiotype. The authenticity of a material object does not equate to the documentary credibility of its content. However, a historical process can make the artist’s participation in the creation and materialization of an image more visible. This is particularly important in the case of Roberto Roberti, whose practice is based on the fusion of digital and historical technologies. There is no clear line separating contemporary photography from traditional photography. Digital negative preparation allows for contact printing, while handwork gives the image its specific form. Artistic value stems not from the exclusive use of any one technology, but from the manner in which it is applied.

Despite his commitment to materiality, Roberto Roberti does not idealize the conditions of contemporary alternative photography. In his responses, he notes the significant increase in the cost of platinum, palladium, and gold toning agents. He admits that he has reduced the number of prints he makes, although he believes regular practice is essential to maintaining and honing his skills. Gum dichromate remains relatively inexpensive in terms of basic materials, but it requires a significant investment of time and responsible handling of waste containing chromium(VI) compounds. These statements bring a necessary realism to considerations of slow photography . Slowness can be an artistic value, fostering concentration and mindfulness, but it also entails economic and organizational constraints. Materials have a price, the process requires a certain amount of time, and historical technology is not immune to environmental issues. The choice of technique therefore remains an artistic decision made in the specific circumstances of life and work.

It’s no coincidence that Roberto Roberti attaches importance to these limitations. Making prints himself requires him to constantly negotiate the relationship between the desired result and the possibilities of achieving it. In palladiotyping, technological precision and the cost of materials are particularly crucial. In gum bichromate, the time-consuming, multi-layered, and unpredictable process play a greater role. Each technique offers a certain degree of freedom, but each also sets limits. In this sense, the question of authorship, which served as the starting point for analyzing his work, proves to be broader than the choice between mechanical fidelity and manual intervention. It concerns the artist’s ability to recognize the possibilities and limitations of the process, to decide on the extent of his own control, and to accept a given result as final.

Historical pictorialists sought arguments for the artistic autonomy of photography. Roberto Roberti’s contemporary practice demonstrates that this autonomy need not be justified by photography’s similarity to painting or the intensity of manual image transformation. It can be recognized in the individual way in which the entire creative process is organized, from the decision regarding the motif to the selection of the final material form of the photograph. The most interesting aspect here is a certain apparent contradiction. Roberto Roberti particularly values ​​techniques that allow him to achieve the highest material quality of a print, but at the same time consciously differentiates the scope of his own involvement in shaping it. In one case, he strives to preserve the image, in the other, he allows for its transformation. Both decisions stem from the belief that the process should correspond to the photograph, rather than photography being merely a pretext for employing a specific technique.

Perhaps this is where the most important connection between his practice and the legacy of pictorialism becomes apparent. It’s not about the obligation of manual intervention, nor the belief that a historical print possesses inherently higher artistic value. What remains crucial is the ability to consciously determine the role of the process in the creation of the work. A photograph can be completed before a print is made, if the artist determines that its composition and tone require no further changes. It can also remain open to further decisions during the application of pigment, exposure, and development. However, the boundary between these situations does not end where digital photography ends and the historical process begins. It is established by the individual artist, who recognizes the moment at which further action would enhance the image or detract from its intended character.

In Roberto Roberti’s practice, the transition from image to print is not a simple technological progression. It is an area of ​​artistic responsibility, where decisions can be made both about further creation and about the end of the process. The history of pictorialism provides this choice with an important context, but it does not define its ultimate limits. It leaves these to the photographer, his experience, sensitivity, and ability to recognize when an image has reached its desired form.

Footnotes

  1. R. Demachy, “On the Straight Print”, “Camera Work” 1907, no. 19, pp. 21-24, https://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/camera_work1907_19 .
  2. The Flatiron , Edward J. Steichen, 1904 negative, bichromate gum on platinum print, 1905 and 1909 versions, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, inventory no. 33.43.44 and 33.43.39, https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/267839 ; https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/267803 .
  3. R. Roberti, written responses provided to the author for the project “From Pictorialism to Post-Photography. The Functioning of Alternative Techniques in Contemporary Art Photography”, October 2026, document in English, unpublished material, author’s archive.
  4. R. Roberti, “Platinum Palladium for Digital Photographers,” Fuji X Passion, March 23, 2018, https://www.fujixpassion.com/2018/03/23/platinum-palladium-digital-photographers/ .
  5. E. Edwards, J. Hart, “Introduction: Photographs as Objects”, in: Photographs Objects Histories: On the Materiality of Images , ed. E. Edwards, J. Hart, Routledge, London-New York 2004, pp. 1-15.
errore: Content is protected !!